Miles Guo Court Documents · Doc 596

摘要

Order Regarding Letters and Motions from Nonparties · April 4, 2025 · Vexatious-Filer Finding and Screening Requirement

A one-page order signed by Judge Analisa Torres on April 4, 2025, following directly on the previous day's order (Dkt. 528).

Six more filings within twenty-four hours

The order recites that by order dated April 3, 2025 the Court had explained the limited circumstances in which a nonparty may file a letter, motion, or other filing in a criminal case; had discussed specific filings by individuals identifying themselves as Chunk Chyi and Bei Bei Zhu; had explained why those filings were improper and, in some instances, could be construed as threatening, harassing, or at a minimum vexatious; and had advised that further improper filings could subject the filers to a permanent filing injunction.

In the twenty-four hours since that order was docketed, Chunk Chyi and Bei Bei Zhu filed six additional improper filings (Dkts. 553–57, 582).

Finding and order

The Court accordingly found that the two are vexatious nonparties who have abused the public's right of access to the Court in clear violation of court orders, and ordered that any further filing by either of them, or by any alias or representative thereof, shall be screened and docketed only if the Court determines that the filing is made in accordance with applicable court rules, in good faith, and with a proper basis under the law.

The order also denied the requests filed by nonparty Carolyn Sun at Dkts. 559 and 568.

Afterwards

This pre-filing screening requirement is the object of one petitioner's request, among the six pro se mandamus petitions the Second Circuit consolidated in May 2026, to vacate or suspend it; the Second Circuit denied that request under the Cheney standard (Dkts. 849, 868).